Just thought I'd point out the two bloggers in TheAtlantic.com crew that I try to keep up with:
Andrew Sullivan and
Ta-Nehisi Coates.
In a post from earlier this afternoon, Sullivan excerpts and gives big ups to TNC--as apparently Rachel Maddow did via her twitter. I don't disagree with her sentiment either:
Riding The Five Train
Maddow tweets that she doesn't "know if in US commentary there is a more beautiful writer than Ta-Nehisi Coates" and points to his recent post on obesity, class, and race. Hard to disagree:
When I lived in Brooklyn, the most depressing aspect of my day was the commute back home. The deeper the five train wended into Brooklyn, the blacker it became, and the blacker it became, the fatter it got. I was there among them--the blacker and fatter--and filled with a sort of shameful self-loathing at myself and my greater selves around me. One of the hardest thing about being black is coming up dead last in almost anything that matters. As a child, and a young adult, I was lucky. Segregation was a cocoon brimming with all the lovely variety of black life. But out in the world you come to see, in the words of Peggy Olson, that they have it all--and so much of it. Working on the richest island in the world, then training through Brooklyn, or watching the buses slog down 125th has become a kind of corporeal metaphor--the achievement gap of our failing bodies, a slow sickness as the racial chasm.
Cool to know that TNC lived in Brooklyn. He lives in Harlem now, as he often mentions on his blog (indeed, as he alludes to in the post above, "watching the buses slog down 125th").
If he lived deep in Brooklyn off the 5, it must have been Crown Heights, Prospect Lefferts Garden, or Flatbush that he resided in.
I take the 4-5 back to Bk for about 30% of my commutes. My stop is at Brooklyn's grand central subway junction, Atlantic-Pacific (the center of The Planet, as I like to think of it). At that point, the 4-5 are running together down the same line, which they do through all of Manhattan and into Brooklyn.
They continue running together from Atlantic-Pacific, under Flatbush Ave to Grand Army Plaza, and they veer together under Eastern Parkway into Crown Heights. The Eastern Parkway stop is the next one on the 4-5 after Atlantic Pacific.
I'll have to collect some rough data, but I'd say non-blacks will be in the minority on any given 4-5 train as soon as you go past Bowling Green--last stop in "the richest island in the world"--and drop down under the Harbor and go into Brooklyn.
But once you pass Atlantic-Pacific, I can't imagine that more than 5% of the people (so 1 out of 20, so maybe 3 or 4 on a full car?) on your average train are going to be non-black.
The last time we took the 4-5 deeper into Brooklyn was Labor Day, for the West Indian Day Parade. We came up on Eastern Parkway and it was wall-to-wall people--to the point where we hardly moved for half an hour. I've got to finally post some pics from that day.
After the Eastern Parkway stop, the 4 and 5 finally part ways, with the the 5 taking a hard turn south, into the above-mentioned neighborhoods. The 4 continues eastward for one more stop, which would put you out in what I believe is Brownsville. I've never been out there.
I've taken the 5 further a few times--to catch installments of the MLK Jr concert series: free shows by pretty big names, for a run of about 10 shows each summer. Those are held at Wingate Field, a few blocks from the Winthrop stop of the 5 (and the 2, which are running partners down there), across from the imposing Kings County Hospital.
Comments [0]